Choice, Community and the Value of Independent Education in Scotland

There has been much discussion in recent months about the introduction of VAT on independent school fees, and it is right that we take the time to reflect carefully on what this means for families, schools and the wider Scottish education system.

At its heart, this is a question of choice.

For many families across Scotland, choosing an independent school is not about exclusivity or advantage. It is about finding the right environment for their child — academically, pastorally and personally. It is about smaller class sizes, strong relationships, breadth of opportunity, and the ability to tailor learning in a way that helps each child to flourish.

That freedom of choice matters. It reflects the diversity of children themselves.

Recent analysis highlighted in The Times, including commentary from Lorraine Davidson, suggests that the introduction of VAT is already having measurable consequences. Independent school rolls in Scotland have fallen by around 9%, with an estimated 900 jobs lost and a £60 million impact on the Scottish economy.

Longer term, the projected cost to the public purse could reach £200 million annually. But there are other, less tangible costs, such as the strain on the already overburdened state system with over 4 in every 10 pupils having an Additional Support Need in Scotland’s classrooms. How on earth can this be sustained?

These are not abstract figures. They represent real families reconsidering decisions, real staff losing roles, and real pressure building elsewhere in the system.

When a family feels that independent education is no longer financially viable, their child does not disappear from the system — they move into the state sector. That, in itself, is not problematic. What is concerning is the pace and scale at which this shift may happen, and whether it is being matched with the resources required to support it.

Scotland’s education system has long been a mixed economy, and that has been a strength. Independent schools contribute not only through education, but through employment, community engagement, partnerships, and increasingly through bursaries and widening access initiatives. They are part of the fabric of Scottish education, not separate from it.

For parents, the question is often a very personal one: Where will my child be happiest? Where will they be known, supported and challenged?

It is important that families continue to feel they have agency in answering that question.

None of this is to argue that independent education should be beyond scrutiny, or that it does not have a responsibility to demonstrate its value. It does, and it must. But policy decisions in this space must be grounded not only in principle, but in a clear understanding of their wider impact.

If the goal is to strengthen education for all children in Scotland, then we must ensure that we do not unintentionally narrow the choices available to families, or destabilise parts of the system that are working well. Because at its heart, this is not a debate about sectors or structures.

It is about children — and about ensuring that every family in Scotland retains the ability to choose the environment in which their child can truly thrive. Strong education systems are built not on uniformity, but on choice, diversity, and the ability to meet children where they are.

And that is something worth protecting.